Waves and Echoes: A Process of Re-contemporarization in Chinese Art Circa 1987 Revisited
November 2020 – 9 May 2021
Inside-Out Art Museum, No.50 Xingshikou Road, Haidian District, Beijing
Curators: Liu Ding, Carol Yinghua Lu
Assistant Curators: Huang Wenlong, Sun Gaorui
Visiting Curators: Liu Yusi, Zhang Ligeng
Inside-Out Art Museum proudly presents Waves and Echoes: A Process of Re-contemporarization in Chinese Art Circa 1987 Revisited, a major research exhibition. Waves and Echoes is the latest project in the research series “The Echoes of Socialist Realism,” after Salon, Salon: Fine Art Practices from 1972 to 1982 in Profile –A Beijing Perspective, which was held at IOAM in 2017. Initiated collaboratively by artist Liu Ding and art historian Carol Yinghua Lu, this research series aims to critically analyze and reflect on the historical narratives and constructs about contemporary art in China.
Regarding the 1980s, there has existed a considerable amount of narratives, including documentations and memories, summaries and reflections. Since then, a plethora of historical writings have come to promote certain viewpoints. All of these narratives around New Wave Art (xinchao meishu) of 1985 and 1986, tend to define the feeling, consciousness, and understandings of the whole period of the 1980s. Through them, historical writings about art of the 1980s have enforced a homogeneity. In art history, the 1980s, thus has become a generalized and unvaried historical canon. As a result, it’s impossible to grasp and comprehend the multiple and complex turns throughout this historical period.
Driven by the Intellectual Emancipation Movement (sixiang jiefang) as well as Reform and Opening-up (gaige kaifang), the Cultural Fever (wenhuare) went up in heat as it unfoloded through the 1980s. Its accretion by 1985 and 1986 led to the emergence of New Wave Art as a highlight. This period was animated by dynamic artistic works and discourses in the art world. However, by the end of 1986, the art world rapidly experienced an ebbing of the tide. The New Waveperiod’s surge and crest rapidly fell to a nadir. Although the voices of reflection persisted during the movement, they were only further developed after the Anti-Bourgeois Liberalization Campaign (fanzichan jieji ziyouhua) in 1987.
In 1987, the art world became stagnant, but the theorization and historicization of the New Wave Art quietly began. Some theories and practices began to get ossified, slowly deviating from actual artistic practices. Artists no longer appeared in the form of groups. Instead, the work of individual artists gradually came to the forefront. Many individual artists, having undertaken varied artistic turns through the 1980s, henceforth showed distinctive choices of direction in their standpoints. The stance and orientation of their artistic practices became increasingly crystalized from this point on.
Artistic practices before 1987 can be described as heteroglossic, while later ones can be considered as gradually smoothing out and moving closer to the contracted reality. Though the ideological spaces of the society were subject to restrictions, possible spaces for cultural activities diversified. Thus, artists and their practices grew more connected with social spaces in every way.
This research project considers the year of 1987 as a framing point for further scrutinization. One aspect to consider is that 1987 can be regarded as a time marker distinguishing the mid 1980s from the late 1980s. To a definite degree, 1987 initiated a change in the mindset of Chinese society from short-lived pluralism towards institutionalization. Another aspect to consider and investigate is the ideological motivation for changes in artists’ works; one can reconsider how the empirical experiences and intellectual resources of the early-to-mid 1980s were complicated, absorbed, diluted, and even constructed by an intricate reality, thus forming various forms of artistic expressions from this point on.
This exhibition proposes “re-contemporarization” as a theoretical model for interrogating history and grasping the post-1949 transformation of Chinese art and thought. Though suppressions of differing trends and opinions by mainstream art have long existed during different periods of time, in a broader viewpoint of history, one can fall into the trap of generating an exclusive and fractured historical narrative if only suppressed elements of history are highlighted in efforts of historical re-examination. If certain points of time since Reform and Opening-up are taken as a starting point for evaluating contemporary Chinese art, it’s easy to be trapped by a Western, neoliberal perspective that places itself as a universal model for comparison. The adaptation of modernism by Chinese artists in the 1980s does not entirely reflect on a process of the latecomers learning the path of the Western forerunners, but to a large degree, a process of knowledge renewal of the Chinese art field dated back to the 1920s-1930s when it first started to introduce and criticize Western modern art.
This research considers those drastic reforms of art since 1949 and the sculpting, regulating and interfering of artistic forms, discourses, and viewpoints as part of the contemporarization process of Chinese art. This kind of historical perspective may allow a closer examination of artistic discourses and practices that have always been entangled into mainstream ideologies. This is also the context and premise on which all practitioners act in today.
In Waves and Echoes, the curators engage into a dialogue with existing historical narratives and researches on the basis of recognizing their value. Through careful refining of theory and praxis situated in historical contexts, horizons of understanding can be widened. They put the 1980s in a broader historical context and reconstruct the historical relationships between the category of the 1980s and the artistic and literary developments from 1949 to Reform and Opening-up. As such, the historical thread of thoughts in the art of the 1980s becomes much clearer. This research not only holistically takes hold of the 1980s, but also avoids making simple distinctions based upon existing ideologies. Through 1987 as a time marker, the curators demonstrate both the ruptures and continuities between contemporary art and contemporary mainstream culture, thus breaking through the constraints of the “contemporary model“ set by Western/North American intellectual circles. With an aim to apporach the present by critically looking into the past, this pioneering research continuously integrates deliberation of current issues and reflections into the revisit of the 1980s.
Chen Shaoping, Chen Wenji, Chen Zhen, Pond Society (Zhang Peili, Geng Jianyi, Song Ling, Bao Jianfei, Wang Qiang, Guan Ying), Ding Fang, Ding Yi, Feng Guodong, Fu Zhongwang, Geng Jianyi, Gu Dexin, Gu Wenda, Robert Rauschenberg, Li Bangyao, Li Laoshi, Li Luming, Li Qingping, Li Shan, Li Xiaobin, Li Xiushi, Lin Chun, Lin Dachuan, Lin Gang, Lu Shengzhong, M Art Group (Yang Hui, Song Haidong, Zhao Chuan, Hu Yuelong, Li Zuming, Gong Jianqing, Shen Fan, Tang Guangming, Yang Xu, Wang Guqing, Weng Liping, Fu Yuehui, Qin Yifeng, Yang Dongbai, Zhou Tiehai), Mao Xuhui, Meng Luding, Min Xiwen, Southern Artists’ Salon (Wang Du, Chen Shaoxiong, Lin Yilin, Huang Xiaopeng, Liang Juhui etc.), Pang Tao, Qin Yifeng, Sha Qi, Shang Yang, Shu Qun, Song Haidong, Song Ling, Sun Liang, Wang Rizhang, Wang Guangyi, Wang Hao, Wang Luyan, Wang Youshen, Wei Qimei, Wen Pulin, WR Group (Datong Dazhang, Zhu Yanguang, Ren Xiaoying etc.), Wu Guanzhong, Xiamen Dada (Huang Yongping, Lin Jiahua, Jiao Yaoming, Yu Xiaogang, Lin Chun, Ji Tairan, Cai Lixiong, Chen Chengzong, Li Yuenian, Li Xiang, Wu Yanping, Huang Ping, Liu Yiling, Shen Yuan, Xu Chengdou, Huang Ming), Xu Bing, Xu Lei, Yang Jiechang, Yang Zhilin, Ye Qianyu, Yu Youhan, Zhang Guoliang, Zhang Jianjun, Zhang Peili, Zhang Wei, Zhang Xiaogang, Zhuang Huayue